Thursday, April 26, 2007

Butler on Kindred

Octavia ButlerHere's an excerpt from an interview with Octavia Butler from 2004, twenty-five years after the publication of Kindred:

Joshunda Sanders: Why do you think Kindred has been one of your more popular works?

Octavia Butler: Because it's accessible to a number of audiences: black studies, oh, I guess I have to modify my vocabulary here -- African American studies, women's studies and science fiction. It sometimes reaches people who might not otherwise read that kind of book, who might not read a history, a historical novel even about that period unless it was a Gone With the Wind type.

[With Kindred] I chose the time I was living in. I thought it was interesting to start at the bicentennial and the country's 200 years old and the country's still dealing with racial problems, and here's my character having to deal with slavery all of a sudden. If I had written the book now, it probably wouldn't be very different. What I was trying to do is make the time real, I wanted to take them back into it. The idea was always to make that time emotionally real to people. And that's still what it's about. The nice thing is that it is read in schools. Every now and then I hear about younger kids reading it and I wonder how they relate to it. All too often, especially young men, will feel, "Oh, if it was me, I would just..." and they have some simple solution that wouldn't work at all and would probably get them killed. Because they don't really understand how serious it is when the whole society is literally arrayed against you and arrayed to really keep you in your place. If you get seriously out of line, they will kill you because they fear you.

Kindred was kind of draining and depressing, especially the research for writing it. I now have a talk that begins with the question, "How long does it take to write a novel?" and the answer is, as long as you've lived up to the time you sit down to write the novel and then some. I got the idea for it in college. But a lot of my reason for writing it came when I was in preschool, when my mother used to take me to work with her.

I got to see her not hearing insults and going in back doors, and even though I was a little kid, I realized it was humiliating. I knew something was wrong, it was unpleasant, it was bad. I remember saying to her a little later, at seven or eight, "I'll never do what you do, what you do is terrible." And she just got this sad look on her face and didn't say anything. I think it was the look and the memory of the indignities she endured. I just remembered that and wanted to convey that people who underwent all this were not cowards, were not people who were just too pathetic to protect themselves, but were heroes because they were using what they had to help their kids get a little further. She knew what it was to be hungry, she was a young woman during the Depression; she was taken out of school when she was ten. There were times when there was no food, there were times when they were scrambling to put a roof over their heads. I never had to worry about any of that. We never went hungry, we never went homeless. I got to go to college and she didn't even get to finish elementary school. All that because she was willing to put up with this nonsense and try to help me. I wanted to convey some of that and not have it look as though these people were deficient because they weren't fighting. They were fighting, they just weren't fighting with fists, which is sometimes easy and pointless. The quick and dirty solution is often the one that's most admired until you have to live with the results.

The entire interview is available here.

Monday, April 23, 2007

Plot hole

I'm confused... Pages 141 and 193 both mention Vessey, the man who planned to lead South Carolinian slaves in revolt. However, it seems as though Vessey's actions are taking place at two different times. Perhaps I missed something and both times are in the past, but I'm still not sure how Kevin is present in the second time. If someone could help me, that would be great!

Sunday, April 22, 2007

Rufus and Mr. Weylin

After reading more of Kindred, what does everyone think of the relationship between Rufus and his father? Is it what it should be? Is is unhealthy or healthy? Must we take into consideration the time period and the cuture at hand?

Wednesday, April 18, 2007

Is someone at the door?

I just wanted to agree with Amy that this book is a page turner and captures my interest. After reading about Carrie comming up with food [p181], I started thinking about my own lunch. Suddenly, I realized I was waiting for some friend of mine to knock on my door, bringing food for us to eat... I guess if the book gets me to remember the events in it as though they're my memories, then it's a great book. ^_^

Saturday, April 14, 2007

Octavia Butler's Kindred

I (along with everyone else I'm sure) find this book very interesting. It's a real page turner. Something that ouccured to me as I was reading this was how Dana was treated concerning her relationship with Kevin. She is really his wife, but they have to play the roles of slaveowner and slaveholder. Does anyone have any reflections about how they dealt with this difficulty?

Video proof of superhuman speed

Okay, everybody. Here it is . . .

Thursday, April 12, 2007

Kindred

I really enjoyed reading this story. It is a real page turner. Parts of it remind me of Tony Morrison's Beloved. Rufus's innocence seem to make Dana feel a lot more comfortable with the situation she is in, which I found odd. I would personally feel more comfortable around my peers instead of a child but I guess when she figured out he was the same boy she saved from the river she wasn't comfortable with his parents. The suspense and longing to know exactly what is going to happen to Dana makes this a real page turner.

Does anyone feel that Dana is sent to help Rufus in order to keep her heritage alive? Do you feel that if Dana wasn't sent to help him in these events which could have resulted in him dying it would change her family history at all? Do you think the reason for her meeting Rufus was to lead her to Alice, if so why do you think she was sent to Alice?

A Conversation with Octavia Butler

Click here for that interview with Octavia Butler I mentioned in class on Wednesday.

(By the way, you probably noticed I changed the template for the blog. Some strange formatting problems were occurring when I tried to publish this post, so I just changed the template. Doing so seems to have solved the problem.)

Sunday, April 8, 2007

Trifles

Mrs. Hale seems to accuse herself of not being a friendly neighbor. I was wondering if anyone agreed with her that she is guilty. In one sense, she accuses herself of killing Mr. Wright since if Mrs. Wright had another person to talk to other than her bird, she would not have had the desire to kill her husband. Of course, this is all speculation Mrs. Hale seems to have. It would be good to note that if her theory were true, instead of Mr. Wright killing the bird, he may have killed Mrs. Hale.

Tuesday, April 3, 2007

“A &P” by John Updike and “The Secret Spot” by Alice Elliott Dark

"A & P" by John Updike

The story is basically about a boy who quits his job just because the manager talked bad to some girls who were wearing swimsuits inside the store.
Do you think Sammy's reason for quitting was worth it even though the girls did not even notice him?
In the story Sammy says: "But it seems to me that once you begin a gesture is fatal not to go through with it." Do you think he is right or do you think we can change our mind at any point in any situation?

"The Secret Spot" by Alice Elliott Dark

In the story Helen believes Julia had a affair with her husband. At the end Helen discovers that the affair never happened and that it was her husband who liked Julia. Julia seems to be a nice person, but Helen stills hates her.
Do you think Helen is right in hating Julia even though is not Julia's fault that Helen's husband likes Julia?

Sunday, April 1, 2007

"Killings" by Andre Dubus

This short story tells of a mother and father struggling with the death of their son, who has been shot by the ex-husband of his current love interest. The interesting twist is that the parents know who the killer is and, because they live in a relatively small community, must see him on a regular basis. My question is this: Do you believe that Matt did the right thing in killing Richard, or should he have let the justice system take its course? Furthermore, what would you have done if you found yourself in Matt's situation?

Tuesday, March 27, 2007

Aria- Rodriguez

This is a different side of the story being told by a minority when it comes to assimilation. Rodriguez believes that its important for immigrants to join into the mainstream if they want to have a life here espeically when it comes to education. However, many the arguments today is that the minorites will lose some sense of their idenity because they will have lost some of their culture. Do you agree with Rodriguez that there shouldn't be bilingual education? He is also against affirmative action. He writes this essay in 1982 and this is still very much a huge issue within education and the work field....whats are your general thoughts?

Saturday, March 24, 2007

"After Welfare" by Katherine Boo

In this essay, Elizabeth, a struggling mother of three, realizes that the "reformed" welfare system put in place to assist them may not be as helpful as it is supposed to be. Many of the middle class people in America think that welfare is providing too much, while the poor class, who are on welfare, believe that welfare is not doing enough. From Boo's essay, and from other experiences, do you think welfare is doing too much or not nearly enough? Are there flaws in the system that prevent it from providing any relief?
Also, do you think that children put in the situations that Elizabeth's kids find themselves are at a disadvantage as compared to kids growing up in middle class neighborhoods?

Thursday, March 22, 2007

A Raisin in the Sun

Who do you think is the main character in the play? Why?

Thursday, March 15, 2007

The Rich Brother

Do you think that Donald is right when he said that Pete doesn't have any purpose in life? Does this statement have any connection with Pete's attempts to kill his brother?

"And the Lord said to Cain: Where is thy brother Abel? And he answered: I know not: am I my brother's keeper?"-Genesis 4:9

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

"The Lesson" by Toni Cade Bambara

The way in which Bambara chooses to end her story leaves the reader wondering if the author learned anything from Miss Moore. Do you think Miss Moores teaching technique was effective in teaching the author? Why or why not?

Sunday, March 11, 2007

E.M. Forster's "My Wood"

E.M. Forster"If you own things, what's their effect on you?"

That's the question E.M. Forster poses in his essay "My Wood." He comes up with several answers based on his own experiences with owning property and material goods. Considering of your own experiences in this regard, how would you answer the question? Do your experiences exemplify some (or all) of the consequences Forster lists in his essay? Are there other consequences of ownership not mentioned by Forster that you can identify?

By the way, here's a web page where someone has annotated Forster's essay, explaining many of his allusions.

Wednesday, February 21, 2007

"Ethics" and "Lying in a Hammock..."

Each of the poems that we read discuss some sort of nature - be it the trees and the sun or the nature of getting old. Both speak of life and half-hearted responses and wasting life. So my questions are:
Which would you choose, the old lady or the Rembrandt (and you can't make the lady choose) and why? Furthermore, what can we, as readers, take from this question in relation to this unit's theme of "Getting By"?
What affect does the color imagery (bronze butterfly, black trunk, green shadow, golden stones) have on James Wright's poem?
Enjoy!

Monday, February 19, 2007

Throughout this story O'Brien discusses the things the men most often carried whether they were necessary or not. In your own opinion, what items do you feel would be necessary to survive something like this both physically and mentally?

O'Brien, as stated in the introduction, is "ambiguous about how his work incorporates his own Vietnam experiences. Do you feel that the detail he uses to describe the people and events helps make this work of fiction more believable, as if O'Brien actually experienced them first hand?

This excerpt comes from Tim O'Brien's book The Things They Carried. The book is wonderful; I highly recommend it. If anyone is interested in reading it I have a copy of the book in my room if you would like to borrow it.

Sunday, February 18, 2007

Orientation

I am unsure if I am doing this right but here it goes. It seems that Orozco, like the other authers we have read, is describing how people have become more like "machines" in the work force. This particular story describes a job where workers can be fired for almost anything, such as asking too many questions. Is Orozco suggesting that these workers have no individual importance and are simply replacable? As well, this story discusses many of the workers personal lives and individual tendancies but states that none of them are to be acknowledge. For example, the workers do not acknowledge that they are working with a serial killer because he is one of their best workers. Is Orozo argueing that the work force today is solely concerned with making money and suggesting that morality, friendship, justice, and other virtures have less importance or no importance within the work force today?

Thursday, February 15, 2007

Just The Facts!!

hey everyone!! sorry I'm posting so late. I've been at the doctors like all day for 2 days straight ugH! but anyway so here is what i got out of Campo's essay! i definitely think he points out how poeple today just fly through life and never take the time to really think about the effect they could have on someone else's life or even day! His patient just wanted someone there for him because he had been abandoned by his friends and didn't have anyone to talk to or smoke a good cigar with! Campo also identifies the importance that people put on labels and statistics. We all wait for the doctor's opinion because he has the final say in a diagnosis, yet they are only human. In today's world we look at statistics to tell us how life. Either its 4 out of 5 doctors recommend or 9 out of 10 people prefer, but when it comes down to it, they are just number without a story to tell. what do you think is the point Campo was trying to make in his essay!?

Monday, February 12, 2007

"What's so Bad About Being Poor?"

After reading and reflecting upon what Charles Murray has to say, how do you define poverty? Is poverty defined in terms of money or do you define poverty as being unable to live a modest but decent existence?

Saturday, February 10, 2007

On Dumpster Diving

Lars Eighner is a writer known for his stories concerning his time spent homeless in the late eighties, and also for his weighty contributions to gay erotica.

After reading this essay I couldn't help but wonder if dumpster diving can be considered a job. How many in this class consider dumpster diving a job? How do each of you define "work" and what exactly is a "job"?

Just in case anyone was curious, Lizbeth died in 1998 at age 13.

Wednesday, February 7, 2007

Studs Terkel's narratives

Studs Terkel portrays two types of people in his two narratives. The steelworker, Mike Lefevre works because he loves his child while the mason, Carl Bates, works for the love of his job. I was curious which one everyone thought was a “higher” reason to work. Perhaps each approaches work from a different way and a synthesis is best. I would like to point out that Lefevre’s work centers on providing for others, and Bates’s love for his job could be applied to any job, including that of worshiping God which is the primary job that the Belmont Abbey monks perform. Have fun!

Tuesday, February 6, 2007

Charlie Chaplin's Modern Times

For your enjoyment -- and to illustrate some of the issues we'll be discussing over the next few classes -- here's a clip of a famous sequence from Charlie Chaplin's 1936 film Modern Times:

Sunday, February 4, 2007

My Essay Topic

My paper topic is on the essay "Femininity" by Susan Brownmiller.

Friday, February 2, 2007

Topic

My paper will be about "The Common Life."

Thursday, February 1, 2007

paper topic

I will be writing my paper on "The Androgynous Man".
I'll be writing mine on "The Common Life"

Patrick Kuhlman's Post

I plan on writing my paper on Martin Luther King's "Letter from Birmingham Jail."

Tuesday, January 30, 2007

Femininity

I will be writing my essay on Susan Brownmiller's "Femininity." In the essay, I will argue that Brownmiller is trying to convey to the reader that a woman who posseses a certain zeal which rebels against the traditional obligations for women actually forms the true definition of femininity. In other words, she is re-defining femininity.

Amy Graziano

Monday, January 29, 2007

Islam

While reading Smith's "The Straight Path of Islam," I became very interested in his discussion of this religion I knew very little about. The way he described the surah as "the heartbeat of the Muslim's response to God" really intrigued me. This statement really shows that this one simple prayer, in a way, is the foundation to everything they do in life, it is what keeps their religion alive. Overall I was shocked to see how similar but yet how different the Islamic faith is from my own faith. Smith goes on to discuss the "Five Pillars" of the Islamic faith. I'm not Catholic but I do know a little and I was wondering if the "Pillars" are in a way equivalent to the sacraments of the Catholic faith. If someone who knows more about it could answer this question I would greatly appreciate it.

Arguments, and the brooking thereof

I will be deciding whether Raymond Carver meant there to be one true way of loving, or whether each person's concept of love is different. My decision will be final, I will brook no argument. No brooking of arguments there shall be.

Sunday, January 28, 2007

Posting/Paper

In order to get to where I am at I went to the blog page for Argumentative Prose and clicked 'sign in' in the top right corner, signed in and then clicked 'new post' under the Argumetative Prose blog!

For my paper I believe I will be writing about Raymond Carver's "What We Talk About When We Talk About Love". I thought this story was really interesting in the different kinds of love that it discussed and which love is the 'supreme' or 'highest' kind of love.

Amanda

Friday, January 26, 2007

posting/Islam

I signed in under my Google account [making sure I was using the new Blogger sign in with Google and not just Blogger]. I then clicked post under the agrumentative prose topic and I'm here now. ^^

Also, when I read "The Straight Path of Islam," it seemed to contrast somewhat [especially on violence] with a book I read by a man who converted from Islam to Christianity after having taught at the largest Islamic university in the world. The man, Mark Gabriel, seemed to have a decent knowledge on the topic since he has a doctorate in both Islamic and Christian theologies, if Islam calls their's theology. On the other hand, I have also read nice portions of Huston Smith's book The World's Religions and his style always seems to emphasize similarities, draw comparisons, but never draw sharp contrasts. However, if Smith's portrayal of Islam is a true one, I am very happy and smile to think of our similarities.

Brian Zinser

Post Away!

As I said in class, I won't be posting on any of our readings this week. Instead, I'd like for everyone to try to publish a post yourself. Once you've accepted my invitation to become an "author" of the blog, sign into your Google account and publish a post to "Argumentative Prose." Tell us what reading you've chosen to write about for Essay 1, perhaps indicating what you will be focusing on in your interpretation.

Actually, the first one of you who is able to figure out how to publish a post might also say something in your post about how you did it (so the rest can know what to do)!

Thursday, January 25, 2007

Gloria Steinem's "Sex, Lies, and Advertising"

Gloria Steinem was the founder and original publisher of Ms. magazine, and is generally regarded as one of the more influential feminist commentators of the late twentieth century. She certainly addresses feminist concerns in her article, but she also provides some interesting insight into journalism, more generally speaking.

We'll discuss and debate Steinem's argument on Friday. What do you perceive to be Steinem's primary argument here? Also, what rhetorical strategies -- logos, ethos, pathos -- do you see Steinem employing as she makes her case?

Tuesday, January 23, 2007

Raymond Carver's "What We Talk About When We Talk About Love"

I'll be interested to hear whether or not you think Raymond Carver's story illustrates any of the attitudes and/or ideas we found in the essays by Brownmiller and Perrin. Or just comment on any aspect of the story you found interesting or about which you had a question.

By the way, I've now invited everyone to be authors of the blog. Let me know if you didn't get an email from me.

Saturday, January 20, 2007

Susan Brownmiller's "Femininity" & Noel Perrin's "The Androgynous Man"

On Monday we’ll discuss two short essays: Susan Brownmiller’s “Femininity” and Noel Perrin’s “The Androgynous Man.” Both authors are addressing expectations for men and women -- specifically how we are all expected to live up to certain standards of masculinity or femininity (depending on our sex).

While Brownmiller and Perrin have different perspectives and interests, they do seem to agree about certain issues. There are also some interesting differences between the two essays (besides the obvious one that Brownmiller is concentrating on women and Perrin on men).

Leave a comment about how these essays compare. Or simply comment on any claim or observation made by either author you find intriguing.

Wednesday, January 17, 2007

Scott Russell Sanders's "The Common Life"

I have just a couple of questions for you regarding Scott Russell Sanders’s essay “The Common Life.”

First of all, how would you describe “The Common Life” if you were to explain it to someone who has never read it before? What exactly does Sanders seem to be arguing? Is his essay descriptive or prescriptive? In other words, is he merely describing the current situation here in America? Or is he prescribing ways to remedy the current situation? Or both?

Secondly, how does Sanders characterize American life in the 1990s (when he wrote the essay)? In Sanders’s opinion, what do Americans value? And why? And what’s wrong with those values (acc. to Sanders)?

Those of you who haven't created a Google account, go ahead and do so before commenting. Then sign in with your Google account when you leave your comment. If you run into any difficulty, email me or come during my office hours.

Monday, January 15, 2007

Martin Luther King, Jr.'s "Letter from Birmingham Jail"

Martin Luther King, Jr. inside the Birmingham jail from which he wrote his famous letter (photo courtesy National Archives and Record Administration)No class today, as we observe along with the rest of the nation Martin Luther King Day. King’s “Letter from a Birmingham Jail” not only represents an important moment in the civil rights struggle, it is a terrific example of argumentative prose. The letter (written April 12, 1963) is specifically addressed to eight white Alabama clergymen. Though sympathetic to the cause for which King and others were arguing, these clergymen had criticized the need for public protests such as the one for which King had been arrested. (The photograph is of King inside the Birmingham jail.)

Even though the letter is addressed to the clergymen, King obviously had a wider audience in mind. King employs several rhetorical strategies (that is, ways of arguing) to convince his readers of the need for racial equality. As you read King’s “Letter,” try to identify some of those strategies. Where is he particularly effective in making his case, and why?

(If you are interested in some more context for the letter, here’s an interesting site that tells a bit about the protest, King’s arrest, and some reactions/consequences.)

As before, leave your comments below. Don’t post anonymously -- when you are asked to “Choose an identity,” go ahead and select “Other” and then type in your name.

Thursday, January 11, 2007

"The Use of Force" by William Carlos Williams

Hey everybody! If you’re looking for Matt Harding’s “Dancing” video, just scroll down. (Great comments so far, by the way.)

I asked you to read William Carlos Williams’s short story “The Use of Force” for Friday. This post is designed to give you a couple of things to consider after you’ve read the story. I’ll probably bring up these same issues in class on Friday, but feel free to comment here as well.

You might have noticed several moments in the story when Williams uses figurative language (as opposed to literal language). For example, early on the narrator says “The child was fairly eating me up with her cold, steady eyes” (97) -- he means that figuratively, of course. What are some other examples of figurative language in the story? Why do you think Williams chooses to use figurative language sometimes rather than literal language?

Here’s a related question: What is the significance of the title? Sure, it has a literal meaning. But what other, non-literal meanings might it have? This question is another way of asking whether you think the story might have some “symbolic” significance (beyond what literally happens in the story, i.e., a doctor resorting to “the use of force” to treat an uncooperative patient). What other, broader “argument” might Williams be making here?

Thursday, January 4, 2007

"Dancing" by Matt Harding

Here's the short film I mentioned to you during our first class meeting. You can learn more about Matt Harding by visiting his website, called "Where the Hell Is Matt?" The film is about 3½ minutes long.



On the Frequently Asked Questions portion of his website, Harding responds to the question "What is the message of your videos?" by saying "Up to you. I'm just dancing."

Leave a comment by clicking on "Comments" at the bottom right of this post. When you are asked to "Choose an identity," go ahead and select "Other" and then type in your name. (Don't leave an anonymous post.) I'm very interested to hear what you think might be the "message" or "argument" of this short film.

In the near future I plan to give everyone in the class "publishing" rights to the blog. That means you'll be able to submit your own posts (and not just comment).